Відео

Tbh, i feel bad for these idols because I know they're somehow talented but couldn't just showcase it all due to the song and choreography choices of the company. Like how can you sing well while doing hard choreos? How can you belt out those high notes when doing difficult movements? I mean there are idols who can do that but there are also some idols who naturally gets out of breath easily. I think here comes the advantage of having own producers in a group? For example I watched the livestream of my fave group producing a song and while toplining, one of the producers of the group suggested a line which require a tricky breathing technique. Producer 2 of the group pointed out "is it possible to sing that live? Aren't you going to be out of breath?" Producer 1 then demonstrated the proper breathing technique to deliver that line. That's the only time producer 2 agreed and they applied it to the song. I thought at that time, this type of producers is probably what every kpop group need nowadays 😅 the type that will consider the idols circumstances when performing the song live.

Babymonster Ahyeons shouting is so damn annoying

I had the privilege of attending five of Nmixx's univ festival performances on the spot and all the live vocals they served without MR... and of course they sound nothing like those gnarly MR removed vids lol. They are not a good material at all.

I will never understand people who think edited videos are the best way to tell what someone's raw, unedited vocals sound like

I always find haewon's reaction to her voice cracks amusing😂😂....

This software is not perfect. It capture vocal sound from all sound that mix together. If you trained listener, you don't need this software. I am audio amplifier designer, an electronic and embedded engineer. If this software used by professional then it is OK, because professional can interpreted the result properly. It will be controversy if amateur interpreted the result. For train your ear, you need good equipment, like good player (DAC, CD player, phono player), amplifier, speaker or headphone. You need listen many good recordings and acoustics music instruments play directly without sound system (unplug). So you can compare the timbre, dynamic range, attack time, release time, decay time. You learn the quality of studio microphone and live microphone. You should able to know which is backtrack vocal and which is live vocal ONLY BY LISTENING. I don't watch MR Removed videos and I don't care about amateur opinion.

and sadly most K-pop concerts also use pre-recorded vocals layered on the backtrack which cannot be removed by MR software. MR Software like utagoe and audacity only filter the original track/studio version not the prerecorded

solars mic is never off

i actually really like how sm does it, where sm artists (usually) only sing when paid to preserve their vocals... esp when the songs performed are vocally challenging.. granted we KNOW they can sing if they choose to.

You used the worst channel at mr remove as an example

Point is Kpop group is not same as AKB group... that is what Korean want singer sing, dancer dance. simpie. AH

Shuhua is pathetic. No is NOT a *valuable* member. She should’ve got kicked to the curb instead of Soojin who CAN sing.

People can say whatever they want about Blackpink, but these girls can sing live (especially Rosé)

You should see the Cpac 2021 rendition of the anthem and the reklaws from agt's poorly received rendition of their Country's anthem, "o Canada" both were pretty controversial

I've seen them come up in my feed but I've never clicked on them because I wasn't sure what they were and didn't want to waste my time. Glad I never did because they sound like crap. I don't like hearing the pre-recorded vocals on "live" performances because I think it's cheating. If they want to SING then they should cut down on some of the intense choreography. Otherwise just lip sync. I noticed in your "real live vocals" section the groups weren't doing much if any dancing. On an unrelated note - I really like the music in the intervals between sections of this video.

The saddest part is that so many kids actually believe they removed the MR when they only removed half of their voice and the background noise. Only the original creator of the song, can remove MR.

Yujin from IVE should’ve been included!

No because you're going to get a more accurate judgment from a fancam in all honesty. Lol

sincerely nothing infuriates me more than an mr removed with pre-recorded vocals 😭

Considering that they in no way tell you if an Idol is actually singing live or not, no. MR videos got debunked years ago.

As a relatively new Atiny I was genuinely so impressed by how stable they were at cochella like they did so well. And like Ateez is kinda known for having crazy intense choreos

Thank you😊and best of luck with finals!👍

What you mentioned about MR rem videos featuring pre-recorded vocals setting up idols for failure is very much what happened to Le sserafim, They use prerecorded vocals for the first week of promotions and their vocals sound good in those videos but then when they have to perform encores or in coachella their already sub par skillset gets even more attention because of the contrast with their pre recorded mr removed videos going viral in the past.

Haewon voice cracks are a treasure. Especially her and everyone else's reaction. Just proves it's live and she's human. Confidence is when you can laugh and shake it off. Not a fan of MR removed tracks. They always sound metallic detract from the real vocals.

I think MR Removed videos are irrelevant as of now. MR removeds are 90% prerecorded vocals and therefore not accurate, and when the idols sing live more often than not you can hear them without needing to watch mr removed videos because music show sound systems improved in recent years. I do find it funny when stans say MR removed videos are not accurate for the wrong reasons. I’m sorry but no one is trying to make their voices worse, if a video is fake is usually in favor of idols since that gets more views and engagement from fans commenting “[Insert idol] ate CDs yass queen work”.

lmao I love that 15 years later MR removed videos are still misunderstood and controversial 😂

It's very funny to see MR removed videos of aespa when those girlies did not sing live once during their recent promotion on music shows.😂 (Not that they can't sing live I know very well they can so please next time SM let me hear my girls voices 😭 )

I've always hated how Mr removed videos were used as evidence by people who do not know what they're talking about at all. Same thing with vocal analysis but that's for another time

We need a video about XG!!!!

❤️❤️❤️

And Kpop stans simply say they can’t sing forgetting no one sounds flawless while dancing

Could you please also add treasure in your videos about live singing? Its about as live it could get with how much they adlib on stage (even have a deleted performance because of the adlibs xd)

Can you make vidio on vocal ranking of bts and blackpink? I really wanna know the truth about their voices please. ❤ Good luck with exams

I have always found this MR Removed videos weird.

finally u talks about this

MR Removed Videos would be a reliable source for the 1st, 2nd & middle 3rd gen era but with the late 3rd gen, 4th & now 5th gen? It's useless simce you can now use a pre-recorded vocals & microphones are auto pitched so🤷🏾‍♀️

If your UA-cam channel is dedicated to MR removed or AI songs, that's an instant block from me.

the outro is golden

Yeah we should. I want to brag about my favs abilities to sing 😎

How funny using mr remover on nmixx.

MR removed for music show is suck .it pre recorded . If you want to hear their real voice you can hear it on radio show or on their concerts.

the only kpop MR removed videos you can trust are the ones from sketchbook

I think it's much easier to forget about MR removed videos altogether, we only need to watch groups that will sing live as often as possible. And we have a few now, so no excuse, go NMIXX, Baemon etc.

Mr Mr by Girls Generation has one of the best mr removed in kpop

could you do a video on TVXQ/Jaejoong/Junsu? 🥺 Junsu and Jaejoong were recently on Weverse Festival and they were amazing! also when TVXQ debuted they were known as an acapella group

good luck on your studies

Anyone who thinks MR are more reliable than encore stages is probably a fan who doesn’t want to believe some of their favorite idols are bad at singing. A good number of MR were an acapella of the studio recordings.

Include Moonbyul in the live vocals part. Her recent solo comeback was so impressive, you could hear her voice clearly with a demanding choreo. She's so underrated 😭

Idk how long it have been but I think there's way less to almost no Wendy in these type of videos from this channel these days.

To be honest, pre-recorded save so many idols cause if any use of pre-recorded vocals or lip syncing would be banned for any perfomance or time idols would sing „live“ so many would be probably be exposed to be not as powerful of vocalists fans make them out to be. But yea, MR removed videos are unnecessary and don’t really deliver actual proof if an idol is singing live or not